Author name: Shilpa Gupta

Shivani Gupta, is one of the author on our website. She is writing blogs and articles related to education since last 10 years. Her blogs & articles are considered very informational out to all students.

Best CA Inter Costing Study Material: What to Use and How to Practice
Blogs, CA Inter, Costing

The Power of Practice – Best CA Inter Costing Study Material

Best CA Inter Costing Study Material + Practice Plan Best CA Inter Costing Study Material: What to Use and How to Practice By Shivani · Updated September 28, 2026 The best CA Inter Costing study material is ICAI’s official material, plus one good practice book and past papers from ICAI’s BoS portal. This guide is for CA Inter students (Group 2, Paper 4) who feel stuck on what to study. You’ll see what each resource does, how to practice properly, and where Parag Sir’s 8th edition Cost & Management Accounting book fits. The key takeaway: concepts get you started, but practice gets you the marks. What’s in this guide What’s the best CA Inter Costing study material? Why practice beats reading Your CA Inter Costing study material list How to practice well Want guided practice? FAQs About Parag Gupta Sir Key takeaways Start with ICAI’s official material. Every question in it matters. Add one practice book for extra variety. The 8th edition Cost & Management Accounting book by Parag Sir is one option. Solve past papers, RTPs and MTPs on ICAI’s BoS portal to learn the exam pattern. Do theory from ICAI’s material. Use the book for extra questions. Review your mistakes. Then re-attempt tough chapters on a regular schedule. What’s the best CA Inter Costing study material? Let’s be honest. CA Inter Costing can feel tricky. It’s not just about understanding concepts. You’ve got to apply them to different kinds of questions. So the best CA Inter Costing study material isn’t one book. It’s a small stack: ICAI’s material first, then a practice book, then past papers. And the thing that ties it all together? Practice. Yes, that dreaded word. Why practice beats reading Reading feels productive. But it’s solving questions that builds marks. Here’s what practice does for you: Strengthens concepts. You see the small details of each concept when you try to use it. Builds problem-solving skills. Costing problems can get complex. Practice teaches you which approach fits which question. Shows your weak spots. You can’t fix what you haven’t faced. Grows your confidence. The more you solve, the calmer you get. Your CA Inter Costing study material list Here’s the whole stack at a glance: CA Inter Costing study material: what each resource does Resource What it does Use it when ICAI study material Builds your concepts. Your foundation. First, for every chapter 8th edition book by Parag Sir Gives a wide range of extra questions with simple answers. Includes 20 hours of the latest full course. After you finish each ICAI chapter Past papers, RTPs, MTPs (BoS portal) Shows the exam pattern and trains your timing. Once you’ve covered most of the syllabus 59 important questions PDF Focuses on questions for 60+ marks. Short on time, or during revision ICAI study material: your foundation This one’s non-negotiable. Practice every single question in it. Do your theory from here too. CA Inter Cost & Management Accounting book by Parag Sir (8th edition) Once you’ve finished ICAI’s material, add a practice book. Many students pick the 8th edition CA Inter Cost & Management Accounting book by Parag Sir. It has a wide range of questions with simple answers, and it often challenges your ideas by showing another way to look at a topic. It also comes with 20 hours of Parag Sir’s latest full course. Think of it as the CA Inter costing best book for extra practice, not a replacement for ICAI. Past papers, RTPs and MTPs Solve earlier papers and mocks on ICAI’s BoS portal. They help you manage time and get comfortable with the exam format. Parag Sir’s 59 important questions PDF Short on time? Grab Parag Sir’s 59 important questions, made for students aiming at 60+ marks. Download the 59 questions PDF How to practice well Here’s the routine in one picture: Learn from ICAI’s materialTheory and every question Practice from Parag Sir’s bookExtra questions, mixed difficulty Solve past papers and mocksSet a timer, like the real exam Check your mistakesFind out why you went wrong Revise weak chaptersThen repeat from step 2 Repeat until your weak chapters become your strong ones Start with the fundamentals Finish ICAI’s syllabus first. Do your theory from ICAI’s material. Then move to Parag Sir’s book for more questions. Mix it up Solve theory, practical, easy and tough questions. Don’t stick to your favorites. Study your errors Don’t just check the answer and move on. Find out exactly why you went wrong. Time yourself Try to finish each set in the time you’d get in the exam. Keep revisiting Review important and difficult topics regularly. Mix old and new questions. That’s how you get good at this subject. Want guided practice? If you’d rather learn with a teacher, check out our CA Inter Costing classes. Every offline and online student of Parag Sir also gets his exclusive test series as part of the course, so you can test yourself as you go. Still choosing a teacher? Read how to pick the best teacher for CA Inter Costing. For other subjects, see our CA Inter study guide and tips. The bottom line: getting good at CA Inter Costing takes time and effort. Start practicing now, stick with it, and all the best for your exams! CA Inter Costing FAQs What is the best CA Inter Costing study material? The best CA Inter Costing study material is ICAI’s official Cost & Management Accounting material, backed by a practice book and past papers. ICAI’s material builds your concepts. A book like Parag Sir’s 8th edition gives extra questions. Past papers and mocks from ICAI’s BoS portal show you the exam pattern. How does CA Inter Costing study material work? You start with ICAI’s material and finish each chapter’s theory and questions. Then you add a practice book for variety and solve past papers against the clock. Each layer does one job: concepts first, practice second, exam-style timing last. Is the CA Inter Cost & Management Accounting book by Parag

Altman’s Z, H Score, and Argenti’s A Score by CA Parag Gupta
Blogs, CA Final, SCPM

Understanding Financial Health: Altman’s Z, H Score, and Argenti’s A Score

In the field of financial analysis, evaluating a company’s stability and health is essential. Altman’s Z-Score, H Score, and Argenti’s A Score are three well-known models that are employed in this context. With the aid of these models, stakeholders can make well-informed judgements regarding a company’s financial situation. Each model provides distinct insights. Click here to learn Financial health & similar topic of SPOM-set B by Parag Gupta sir. ALTMAN’S Z score H Score The formula is: H = \frac{D_0 (1 + g_L) + D_0 H (g_S – g_L)}{r – g_L}H=r−gL​D0​(1+gL​)+D0​H(gS​−gL​)​ Where: Argenti’s A Score Argenti’s A Score is a diagnostic tool used to identify the risk of corporate failure. It was developed by John Argenti in the 1970s and focuses on three main areas: defects, mistakes, and symptoms. The A Score is calculated by assessing various factors within these areas, such as management quality, financial structure, and operational efficiency. The scoring system is: Each factor is scored, and the total score indicates the likelihood of corporate failure. Conclusion Altman’s Z-Score, H Score, and Argenti’s A Score are powerful tools for assessing the financial health of a company. While the Z-Score focuses on bankruptcy prediction, the H Score evaluates growth potential, and Argenti’s A Score diagnoses the risk of failure. Together, these models provide a comprehensive view of a company’s financial stability, aiding stakeholders in making well-informed decisions. FAQ’s

Mastering the McKinsey 7S Framework: Insights from Parag Gupta Sir
CA, CA Final, SCPM

Mastering the McKinsey 7S Framework: Insights from Parag Gupta Sir

In the ever-evolving landscape of business management, understanding and optimizing organizational performance is crucial. One of the most effective tools for this purpose is the McKinsey 7S Framework, a model that has stood the test of time in helping organizations achieve strategic alignment and operational excellence. In this blog, we will explore the McKinsey 7S Framework, guided by the expertise of Parag Gupta Sir, a renowned faculty for SPOM- Strategic Cost & Performance management (SCPM). What is the McKinsey 7S Framework? The McKinsey 7S Framework is a management model developed by consultants at McKinsey & Company in the 1980s. It is designed to assess and align seven critical elements within an organization to ensure they work harmoniously towards achieving strategic goals. These seven elements are: Check out Parag sir’s video on Mckinsey 7S: The 7S Model: An Integrated Approach Parag Gupta Sir emphasizes that the power of the 7S Framework lies in its holistic approach. Unlike other models that focus on individual components in isolation, the 7S Framework interlinks all seven elements, ensuring that any change in one area is harmonized with the others. This interconnectedness is vital for achieving strategic coherence and operational efficiency. 1. Strategy Strategy is the cornerstone of the 7S Framework. It involves setting long-term goals and determining the best course of action to achieve them. Parag Gupta Sir highlights that a well-defined strategy provides direction and sets the stage for aligning the other six elements. 2. Structure The structure of an organization refers to its hierarchical setup. It defines roles, responsibilities, and the flow of information. An optimal structure supports efficient decision-making and enhances communication across various levels of the organization. 3. Systems Systems encompass the daily processes and procedures that govern organizational activities. Effective systems streamline operations, reduce redundancies, and ensure that tasks are performed consistently and efficiently. 4. Shared Values At the heart of the 7S Framework are the shared values. These are the fundamental beliefs and guiding principles that shape the organization’s culture. Shared values influence employee behavior, organizational ethos, and the overall work environment. 5. Style Style refers to the leadership approach adopted by management. Leadership style affects organizational morale, employee engagement, and the overall effectiveness of management. Parag Gupta Sir emphasizes that adaptive leadership styles that resonate with the organization’s values and culture are crucial for success. 6. Staff The staff element focuses on the organization’s human resources. It involves recruiting, training, and developing employees to ensure they possess the necessary skills and competencies. A talented and motivated workforce is key to executing the organization’s strategy effectively. 7. Skills Skills refer to the specific capabilities and expertise of the organization’s employees. Identifying and nurturing these skills ensures that the organization can meet its strategic objectives and adapt to changing market demands. Applying the McKinsey 7S Framework Parag Gupta Sir provides practical insights into applying the McKinsey 7S Framework in real-world scenarios. Here’s a step-by-step approach: Real-World Examples Parag Gupta Sir enriches his teachings with real-world examples that illustrate the practical application of the 7S Framework. For instance, he discusses how a leading tech company restructured its organization to foster innovation, aligning its strategy, structure, and systems to support a culture of creativity and rapid development. Conclusion The McKinsey 7S Framework is a timeless tool that provides a comprehensive approach to organizational analysis and improvement. By understanding and aligning the seven elements—Strategy, Structure, Systems, Shared Values, Style, Staff, and Skills—organizations can achieve greater coherence, efficiency, and success. Under the guidance of Parag Gupta Sir, mastering the 7S Framework becomes an invaluable asset for students, professionals, and business leaders alike. His expert insights and practical applications make this complex model accessible and actionable, empowering organizations to navigate the challenges of today’s dynamic business environment. For more in-depth learning, insights, and practical strategies, stay tuned to Parag Gupta Sir’s sessions on Strategic Planning and Operations Management. Want to enroll to SPOM-SCPM classes?

CA Final SCPM
Blogs, CA Final, SCPM

Mastering CA Final SPOM-set B exam (2025 onwards): A Guide by Parag Gupta Sir

Introduction There are many obstacles to overcome on the path to becoming a Chartered Accountant, and the CA Final test is one of the most important checkpoints along the way. Among the various subjects you’ll encounter in the CA Final course, CA Final SPOM-set B exam holds a prominent place. Formerly known as CA Final Costing(SCMPE), this subject has evolved and now comes with a new name and a modern twist—it’s now offered as a self-paced online module. One name that sticks out in the CA community to assist you in successfully navigating this subject of SPOM-set B is Parag Gupta Sir. Parag Gupta Sir: A Trusted Mentor Parag Gupta Sir is a renowned educator in the field of Chartered Accountancy. To help you effectively navigate this subject, one name that stands out in the CA world is Parag Gupta Sir. His expertise in SCPM makes him an invaluable resource for those preparing for the CA Final examination. So, if you’re wondering how to prepare for in the CA Final SPOM-set B exam effectively, here are some insights and tips inspired by the teachings and guidance of Parag Gupta Sir: Conclusion Preparing for in the CA Final SPOM-set B exam, now offered as a self-paced online module, may seem challenging, but with the right guidance from educators like Parag Gupta Sir, it becomes an achievable goal. By following the tips and strategies mentioned above and leveraging the resources provided by Parag Gupta Sir, you can navigate this subject with confidence and emerge victorious in your CA Final examination. Remember that passing the exam is only one component of SCPM success. You must also have the information and abilities necessary to function effectively as a Chartered Accountant in the real world. FAQ’s

CA Intemediate GST Classes
CA, ICAI

CA Intermediate GST Classes For CA Student

CA Intermediate GST (IPCC) Classes The objective of this document is to summarize all the updates of CA Intermediate GST Classes (CA IPCC) (Notifications, Circulars, other amendments, and updates) in one place.2 Central tax notifications,1 Integrated tax notification,And also the council has approved the new GST rates for the real estate sector in the 33rd meeting. CA Intermediate GST (CA IPCC) Important Notices 1.0 Notifications:Objective:I. Notification No. 8/2019_Central tax dated 08th Feb.2019:GSTR-7 (Return for TDS) for Jan’19 from 10th Feb’19 to 28th Feb’19 to 28th Feb’19.filing GSTR-3B for Jan’19 from 20th Feb to Feb.19 for Jammu & Kashmir Feb.19 for the remaining states III. Notification No. 2/2019_Integrated tax (Rate) dated 04.Feb.2019:Since the definition of exports and the Sec 54 of the CGST act have been amended to include the supplies to Nepal and Bhutan under definition of Exports, the Notification No.02/2019 was issued to rescind the exemption entry 10D (the exemption of IGST, for the supplies made to Nepal & Bhutan) of the Notification no.9/2017 dated 28th Jun’17. 2.0 CA Inter GST Classes CA Intermediate GST Circulars (CA IPCC): I. Circular No. 88/07/2019 Central Tax dated 01.02.2019:Circular No. 8/8/2017_04.10.2017_”Master circular relevant for the export procedures and refunds” was amended in view of the amendment allowing realization of export proceeds in INR, wherever allowed by the RBI (CA Intermediate/ IPCC). [2(6) of IGST act].Circular No. 38/12/2018_26.03.2018_”Clarification on issues related to Job Work” was amended to in view of the (IPCC) amendment carried empowering the Commissioner to extend the period for return of inputs and capital goods from the job worker and also the RCM on services received from un-registered job workers. [9(4) and 143 of CGST act.]Circular No. 41/15/2018_13.04.2018_” Procedure for interception of conveyances for inspection of goods in movement…………” was amended to in view of the amendment carried out extending the time limit from 7days to 14 days for owner/transporter to pay tax/penalty for seized goods. [Sec 129 of the CGST act]. CA Intermediate GST Updates (IPCC) After observing that the majority of taxpayers are not reporting details in Table 3.2 of GSTR-3B,III. Circular No. 90/09/2019 Central Tax dated 18.02.2019:IV. Circular No. 91/10/2019 Central Tax dated 18.02.2019:In Circular 46/2017_Customs_Dated 24.Nov.17, it was clarified that,In Circular 3/2018_IGST(CA Intermediate)_Dated 25.May.18, it was clarified that, considering the amendments in the Customs Tariff Act (IPCC),This shall be applicable w.e.f. 01.Apr.18.There was no provision in GSTR-1 for changing POS for such B2B supplies. If the supplier and recipient are in the same state, it was considered as Intra-state sales.3.0 33rd GST Council meeting updates (IPCC):I. GST on Residential properties The proposed GST rate for the residential flats are as followed: 1% for the Affordable housing5% for the othersFor qualifying as “affordable housing” below 2 conditions should be satisfied:Carpet area of up to 90 Sqm in non-metropolitan cities/towns and 60 Sqm in metropolitan cities andThe value < 45Laks in both Metro/Nonmetropolitan citiesThe effective date shall be 01.Apr.19.II. Others (IPCC)The existing rates shall continue for the commercial projectsThe taxation on betting and lotteries shall be taken up in the future council meetings. Click Here: CA Intermdiate New Course Also Read- CA Intermediate Courses CA Final Result 2019 CA Final Exam Date Sheet

ICAI Exams
ICAI

ICAI Exam

ICAI Exam – The Institute of Chartered Accountants The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) is the national professional accounting body of India. It was established on July 1, 1949, as a statutory body under the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949, enacted by the Parliament (acting as the provisional Parliament of India) to regulate the profession of chartered accounting in India. ICAI is the second largest professional accounting & finance body in the world. Candidates who wish to take up Chartered Accountancy as a career, are required to enroll for the program at ICAI and qualify all the levels of exams within a stipulated period of time to be certified as a Chartered Accountant. Image – ICAI Exam Dashboard ICAI Exams Level 2019 ICAI Exam level for the new course 2019 Foundation Course (CPT) Intermediate Course (Inter) Final Course (CA Final) ICAI Exam About Features & Details Exam Name – ICAI Exam, CA CPT, CA IPCC, CA Final ICAI Name – Institute of Chartered Accountants of India ICAI Exam Level – National Level Exam Exam Frequency – Twice a year ICAI Exam Mode – Online (CPT) & Offline (Inter & Final) ICAI Exam Duration – Three hours Language – English & Hindi Exam Helpdesk No. – 1800-200-2501 Exam Website – visit ICAI Exam Eligibility 2019 ICAI Exam CPT Eligibility Criteria CA CPT Course is the entry level for Chartered Accountancy Course. Students who have appeared in the 12th class examination conducted by an examining body constituted by law in India or an examination recognized by the Central Government as equivalent thereto can register for the Foundation Course. A candidate who registered for CPT 60 days prior to the first day of the month in which the CPT examination is to be held, i.e., on or before April 1 and October 1, can appear in the CPT examinations to be held in June and December, respectively. Candidates who are Graduate or Post Graduate in Commerce with a minimum of 55% of total marks or its equivalent grade in the examination conducted by any recognized University (including Open University) with certain subjects OR Graduates or Post Graduates in any other stream having secured a minimum of 60% of the total marks or its equivalent grade in the examination conducted by any recognized University (including Open University) are exempted from passing CPT. Read More ICAI Exam Intermediate (IPC) Eligibility A student who has passed the Foundation Examination is eligible for registration to Intermediate Course. A student who is Graduate/ Post Graduate in Commerce having secured in aggregate a minimum of 55% of the total marks or its equivalent grade in the examination conducted by any recognized University (including Open University) by studying any three papers carrying a minimum of 50 marks in a semester/year and cumulatively 100 or more marks over the entire duration of the concerned course out of Accounting, Auditing, Mercantile Laws, .Corporate Laws, Economics, Management (including Financial Management), Taxation (including Direct Tax Laws and Indirect Tax Laws), Costing, Business Administration or Management Accounting or similar to the title of these papers with different nomenclatures or other than those falling under Commerce stream having secured in aggregate a minimum of 60% of the total marks or its equivalent grade in the examination conducted by any recognized University (including Open University)and candidates. defibulators.orgimp source> who have passed the Intermediate level examination conducted by The Institute of Cost Accountants of India or by The Institute of Company Secretaries of India are exempted from qualifying Foundation Examination and can join the Intermediate Course. ICAI Exam Final Eligibility The candidate who have passed the Intermediate examination or Professional Education Examination – II./PCC/IPCC, are eligible to apply for the Final exam. The candidate must also have completed 3 years or 3½ years or must be due to complete, as the case may be, of articled training as on the date of filling the form. The candidate must be serving the last twelve months of articled training including excess leave if any, and due to complete 3 years on or before 31st October 2017. (for PE-II stream student and PE-II stream students converted to IPCC). Read More. CA Final ICAI Exam 2019 Exam Center The ICAI exams are conducted at 197 exam centers across India and abroad. Moreover, ICAI has facilitated CA exam centers in five test cities abroad: Abu Dhabi Dubai Kathmandu Muscat Doha List of Test Cities for CA Exam. Agra Ahmedabad Ahmednagar Ajmer Akola Alappuzha . Aligarh Allahabad Alwar Ambala Amravati Amritsar Anand Anantapur Asansol Aurangabad Badlapur Banswara Bareilly Bathinda Beawar Belgaum Bellary Bengaluru Berhampore Bhagalpur Bharatpur Bharuch Bhavnagar Bhilwara Bhiwandi Bhiwani Bhopal Bhubaneswar Bhuj Bikaner Bilaspur Bundi Burhanpur Chandigarh Chandrapur Chennai Chhindwara Chittorgarh Churu Coimbatore Cuttack Dehradun Delhi Dhanbad Dhule Durg Durgapur Eluru Ernakulam Erode Faridabad Fatehabad Firozabad Gandhidham Gandhinagar Ghaziabad Gondia Gorakhpur Guntur Gurugram Guwahati Gwalior Haldwani Haridwar Hisar Hubli Hyderabad Ichalkaranji Indore Jabalpur Jaipur Jalandhar Jalgaon Jalna Jammu Jamnagar Jamshedpur Jhansi Jhunjhunu Jind Jodhpur Junagadh Kaithal Kakinada Kannur Kanpur Karimnagar Karnal Kishangarh Kolhapur Kolkata Kollam Kota Kottayam Kozhikode Kumbakonam Kurnool Latur Lucknow Ludhiana Madurai Malappuram Mandsaur Mangalore Mapusa Margao Mathura Meerut Moradabad . Mumbai Muzaffarnagar Muzaffarpur Mysore Nagpur Nanded Nashik Navi Mumbai Navsari Neemuch Nellore Nizamabad Noida Ongole Palakkad Palgarh Pali Marwar Panipat Panvel Parbhani Patiala Patna Pimpri-Chinchwad Pondicherry Pune Raipur Rajamahendravaram Rajkot Ranchi Ratlam Ratnagiri Rewa Rewari Rohtak Rourkela Saharangpur Salem Sambalpur Sangli Sangrur Satara Satna Shimla Shimoga Sikar Silliguri Sirohi Sirsa Sivakasi Solapur Sonepat Sri Ganganagar Srinagar Surat . Surendranagar Thane Thiruvananthapuram Thrissur Tinsukia Tiruchirapalli Tirunelveli Tirupati Tirupur Tuticorin Udaipur Udupi Ujjain Vadodara Vapi Varanasi Vasai Vellore Vijaywada Visakhapatnam Warangal Yamuna Nagar Yavatmal ICAI Exam 2019 Contact Information Website – http://www.icai.org.in/ The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (Set up by an Act of Parliament) A-29, First Floor, Administrative Block, ICAI Bhawan Sector-62, Noida(U.P.), P.C.-201301 E-mail: [email protected] Phone No. : 0120-3045994 (Direct) ICAI Exam 2019 The Institute of Chartered Accountancy of India (ICAI) released an official notice regarding the changes introduced in the CA exam pattern from the May

Indian Accounting Standards
ICAI

ICAI releases e-version of a compendium of revised Indian Accounting Standards

Chartered accountants’ body ICAI Thursday said it has released the e-version of a compendium of revised Indian Accounting Standards that incorporate new ICAI standard on leases among other amendments. As part of annual improvements, the Ind AS (Indian Accounting Standards), which is based on International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), undergo regular upgradation due to the issuance of new standards or amendments in existing standards by IFRS, the accounting body said in a release. The e-version of the compendium of Ind AS includes amendments that were made in Companies (Indian Accounting Standards) Amendment Rules and became effective on April 1. “During the previous year, there have been certain amendments to Ind AS which have all been incorporated in appropriate places and relevant standards in this updated a version of the compendium,” the release said. The existing standard on leases has been replaced in the new accounting standards (Ind AS 116). “In the new lease accounting model for lessees, leases will be recognized on balance sheet by recognizing a lease liability with a corresponding ‘right-of-use’ asset,” it said. Ind AS 116 will have an impact on the financial statements of the firms. The extent of the impact would vary across industries depending on the financing and leasing structures prevalent in an industry, the release added. Similarly, the compendium also includes changes that provide guidance as to how uncertainty about a tax treatment should be reflected in the accounting for income tax. Learn More:- ICAI CA Exam 2019 “The compendium of Ind AS will be highly useful to all stakeholders in particular prepares and auditors of financial statements. ICAI will also continue to engage in disseminating knowledge of these standards and the changes through a series of initiatives including webcasts, workshops, training programmes, and certificate courses,” Institute of Chartered Accountants (ICAI) President Prafulla P Chhajed said. Source:- Download Here

ICSI (also ICAI) Charging Rs. 500 for certified copies is illegal
ICAI

ICSI (also ICAI) charging Rs. 500 for certified copies is illegal : Supreme Court

ICSI (also ICAI) Charging Rs. 500 for certified copies is illegal As per a recent judgment of the Supreme Court in ICSI v. Paras Jain [Civil Appeal No. 5665/2014, dated 11-4-2019], the High Court held that educational Bodies cannot charge more than RTI fee for providing certified copies to students. The RTI Fee as per RTI Rules, 2012 read with RTI Act, 2005 is Rs. 10 fixed per application + Rs. 2 per page. Hence, charging of Rs. 500 or Rs. 1000 per copy is illegal. Example: Suppose, a student has written 20 pages. Hence, he can be asked to pay only Rs. 50 (Rs. 10 for application + Rs. 2 per page × 20 pages = Rs. 50). Download Copy of Judgment    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA   CIVIL APPEAL NO. 5665/2014        INSTITUTE OF COMPANIES SECRETARIES OF INDIA (ICSI) v. PARAS JAI ORDER 1. This appeal is directed against the order dated 22.04.2014 of the Delhi High Court wherein, while allowing the Letters Patent Appeal, filed by the respondent herein, it set aside Guideline No.3 notified by the statutory council of appellant–Institute of Companies Secretaries of India (ICSI) and directed it to charge fee prescribed as per Rule 4 of the Right to Information (Regulation of Fee and Cost) Rules, 2005. 2. The factual matrix of the case is that the respondent appeared in the final examination for Company Secretary (ICSI) conducted by the Appellant in December 2012. On being unsuccessful in qualifying the examination, the respondent made an application under the Right to Information Act for inspection of his answer sheets and subsequently, sought certified copies of the same from the appellant. The appellant thereafter has demanded Rs.500/per answer sheet payable for the supply of certified copies of answer book(s) and Rs.450/per answer book for providing inspection thereof respectively as per Guideline No.3 notified by the statutory council of the appellant. It is to be noted that the respondent obtained the said information under the Right to Information Act, 2005. 3. Being aggrieved by the demand made by the appellant, the respondent preferred a Writ Petition before the Delhi High Court wherein the Learned Single Judge dismissed the petition. A Letters Patent Appeal was thereafter preferred by the respondent wherein, the Division Bench quashed Guideline No.3 notified by the appellant and held that the appellant can charge only the prescribed fee under Rule 4, The Right to Information (Regulation of Fees and Cost) Rules, 2005. 4. The short issue before us is when the answer scripts of appellant’s examination is sought whether the fee prescribed under Rule 4 of the Right to Information (Regulation of Fee and Cost) Rules, 2005 payable or that under Guideline No. 3 of the Guideline, Rules and Procedures for Providing Inspection and/or Supply of Certified Copies of Answer Book(s) to Students, framed by the Examination Committee of appellant’s statutory Council at its 148th Meeting held on 14.08.2013. 5. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant argued that it is undisputed that the Right to Information Act, 2005 is applicable to the appellant. However, in light of specific guidelines formulated under the (ICSI) Company Secretaries Act, 1980, the same should be applicable and not that which is provided under the Right to Information Act. He further contends that owing to quashing of Guideline No. 3 by the Division Bench of Delhi High Court, the appellant cannot collect any amount of fee except the one prescribed under Rule 4, The Right to Information (Regulation of Fees and Cost) Rules, 2005 which adds to financial strain on the appellant. 6. On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent submitted that any candidate who seeks his answer scripts under Right to Information Act, 2005 can only be charged under Rule 4, The Right to Information (Regulation of Fees and Cost) Rules, 2005. Further, the learned counsel submits that the candidates must have a choice to seek the answer scripts either by the avenue under Right to Information Act or under the Guidelines of the appellant framed by the examination committee of statutory Council under the (ICSI) Company Secretaries Act, 1980. 7. Having heard the learned counsels appearing for the parties and we have also meticulously perused the record. 8. The appellant is governed by the provisions of the Company Secretaries Act, 1980 (ICSI) and under Sections 15, 15A and 17, the Examination Committee of the statutory Council has framed Guideline No. 3 providing an avenue to the candidates to either inspect their answer scripts or seek certified copies of the same on payment of the stipulated fees. Guideline no.3 stipulates the payment of Rs. 500 for obtaining certified copies and Rs. 450 for seeking inspection of the same. “3. Fee of ₹500 per subject/answer books payable for the supply of certified copies of answer book (s) and ₹450 per answer book for providing inspection thereof respectively. The fee shall be paid through Demand Draft drawn in favor of “The Institute of Company Secretaries of India”, payable at New Delhi.” 9. On the contrary, Rule 4, The Right to Information (Regulation of Fees and Cost) Rules, 2005 stipulates, “4. For providing the information under subsection (1) of section 7, the fee shall be charged by way of cash against proper receipt or by demand draft or bankers cheque or Indian Postal Order payable to the Accounts Officer of the public authority at the following rates:— (a ) rupees two for each page (in A4 or A3 size paper) created or copied; (b) actual charge or cost price of a copy in larger size paper; (c) actual cost or price for samples or models; and (d) for inspection of records, no fee for the first hour; and a fee of rupees five for each subsequent hour (or fraction thereof).” (emphasis supplied) 10. Thus it is clear that the avenue for seeking certified copies as well as inspection is provided both in the Right to Information Act

ICAI, CA

ICAI – New Lease Accounting Standard Now in Effect

ICAI – New Lease Accounting Standard Now in Effect NEW DELHI: The new accounting standard for leases will bring substantial visibility of companies’ lease commitments and improve the quality of financial information about companies, chartered accountants’ body ICAI said Monday. Ind AS 116, which sets out the principles for recognition, presentation and disclosure of leases has been notified by the corporate affairs ministry. The standard is effective from Monday. senior government official said the standard would affect all industries where leases are a predominant component in their businesses and result in more transparency. ICAI President Prafulla P Chhajed said the new standard on leases ushers in a path-breaking reform in accounting for leases and would improve the quality of financial information. Leasing is a well-known and long established form of obtaining financeNSE 1.76 %. The new standard on leases ushers in a substantial change in the accounting for operating leases by lessees and few improvements in the disclosure-related aspects for lessors accounting, according to the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI). It said the key changes in lessees accounting relate to introduction of single lease accounting model by elimination of classification between operating and finance leases, and recognition of gain/loss for sale and lease-back transactions. In the new lease accounting model for lessees majority of leases will be recognised on balance sheet by recognising a lease liability with a corresponding ‘right-of use’ asset,” the release said. The standard would have an impact on three components of financial statements — balance sheet, cash flow statement, profit and loss account. The, extent of impact would vary for each industry depending on the financing and leasing structures prevalent in that industry,” the release said. The institute also noted that the exemptions given for short term leases and low-value asset leases are expected to provide substantial relief from operational complexities to many companies. Ind AS 116 is expected to have a significant impact on various industries, including aviation where airlines mostly operate planes on lease. Leasing of aircraft rather than outright purchase is a common practice in the airlines industry worldwide. Source- Economic times

Scroll to Top